Are You Okay? Leading a School in the Age of the Tech-Lash

Are You Okay? Leading a School in the Age of the Tech-Lash


BY ANDREW DAVIS, HEAD OF SCHOOL

A middle school boy cheers in the classroom


Last Thursday evening, I attended Dr. Jared Cooney Horvath’s talk on the cognitive impact of screens on kids. As I made my way out of the auditorium, a fellow MTS parent caught my eye and asked, with a look of genuine concern, “How are you doing with that? Are you okay?” I smiled and said, “Yes!” And I meant it.

Dr. Horvath’s talk is part of a much bigger national conversation, often called the “tech-lash.” States, major districts, and the news media are all rethinking the use of screens and AI in schools. We’ve been asking the same questions at MTS. In my welcome back letter in August, I wrote that “we will work this year to ensure technology use at MTS is intentional: deepening learning without replacing human relationships or fueling gamified addiction.” In our opening meetings, I told our faculty that human intelligence in the age of AI “asks us to audit and redouble our efforts to use technology only when it deepens student learning or provides targeted assessment and practice more effectively than a piece of paper can.” That commitment is what led me to read Dr. Horvath’s book, The Digital Delusion, ahead of Thursday’s talk.

The book carries far more nuance than a 45-minute evening talk can, and I agree with far more of it than some might expect. As our focus on human intelligence reflects, learning is deeply human. We know and believe that kids learn best from people, not screens. Dr. Horvath makes it very clear that engagement isn’t the same as learning. And schools have too often adopted technology because it was new or shiny, not because anyone has proven it helps kids learn.

On Friday, I joined a small group of Bay Area school leaders for a conversation with Dr. Horvath. His message was notably measured. He said that in schools like MTS, with strong teachers and deeply engaged families, he estimates that technology accounts for about 5% of our challenges, compared to as much as half in other schools. That said, he argues, and I agree, that we still need to get this right. In each use case we discussed, I found myself nodding along to his nuanced answers, which often recognized real potential for learning. Most importantly, I agreed with his framework for evaluating effective use of technology.

As we wrapped up, his advice was simple: don’t rush. He encouraged us to spend the next six months to a year auditing what we use, deciding what counts as real evidence in our own context, and making decisions based on that data, not on fear or hope. As my summer letter suggested, we need to ensure that every tool we use helps kids learn something better than the alternative, in a way that holds up after the device is put away. At the same time, we’ll keep building our curriculum for the tech skills kids genuinely need, like researching well, judging what’s trustworthy, and typing, taught on purpose rather than picked up by accident. Dr. Horvath made the same distinction: build these skills deliberately, rather than assuming kids pick them up.

Finally, AI. Many of you know I’m genuinely excited about the potential for AI to improve learning. My thesis, though, is that AI’s greatest opportunity is when it faces the teacher, not the student. Where our oldest students do use it, the activity is narrow, built by their teacher, and supervised. At MTS, we see very little place for open-ended AI use by students, even on locked-down platforms. Kids, like adults, mostly use it to get answers, and getting answers isn’t learning.

What we are carefully exploring is the narrow set of AI-powered activities our teachers build for our oldest students. In one English class, students receive personalized feedback on their thesis statements through Socratic coaching. While the resulting thesis statements are stronger, we are now focused on our students’ ability to transfer this skill to non-AI-coached writing. This is the exact sort of evidence-check that Dr. Horvath encourages.

At the roundtable, I described our work at MTS as scooping out the bathwater of ineffective tech use while keeping the baby. Independent schools like ours have the people, time, and judgment to do that carefully.

So, am I okay? Yes! Far more than okay. It was reaffirming to hear that we are asking the right questions and staying focused on evidence of learning, not just engagement.

And if you have made it all the way through a blog post this long about screen time on a screen, I am impressed. My long-form reading, like that of our students, has to happen on paper.

 


Photo of Andrew Davis, Head of School

TGIAM is the blog of Andrew Davis, Head of School. TGIAM = Thank  Goodness It's Almost Monday.

Read More